top of page
Search

Male Factor IVF Paths: ICSI, PICSI, TESE & Donor Sperm

Jun 5
3 min read

Updated: Jul 28

When sperm issues show up - low count, poor motility, abnormal shape, high DNA fragmentation, or previous fertilisation failure - the IVF pathway often changes.

 

Instead of “standard IVF,” you and your doctor may discuss other options like ICSI, PICSI, TESE, or even donor sperm.

 

This chapter explains each option: what it is, who it’s for, and how it affects the treatment plan.

 

1. ICSI (Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injection)

 

What it is

Instead of letting sperm try to fertilise an egg in a dish, an embryologist picks up a single sperm and injects it directly into the egg.

 

Why it exists

To bypass male-factor issues that stop sperm from reaching or penetrating the egg.

 


Who it’s for

 

ICSI is typically recommended when:

  • Sperm count is low

  • Motility is low

  • Morphology is very poor

  • DNA fragmentation is high

  • Previous IVF fertilisation failed

  • Sperm have difficulty penetrating the egg

  • There’s a history of vasectomy

  • Sperm were surgically retrieved

  • Severe male-factor infertility is diagnosed

 

Does it improve embryo quality?

 

Not automatically - ICSI doesn’t fix DNA damage.

It simply removes the “fertilisation barrier.”

 

If the sperm’s DNA is healthy, outcomes can be excellent.

If DNA fragmentation is high, embryo development may still be affected - which leads to our next tool…

 

2. PICSI (Physiological ICSI)

 

A more selective form of ICSI where sperm must bind to hyaluronic acid before being injected.


Healthy, mature sperm naturally bind to hyaluronan in the female reproductive tract, and PICSI tries to mimic that natural selection, since sperm that bind to hyaluronan tend to have lower DNA fragmentation, be more mature, and may produce better embryos.


PICSI may be useful when DNA fragmentation is high, sperm immaturity is suspected, morphology is very low, there have been repeated implantation failures, or embryo quality is unexpectedly poor.

 

What the evidence says

 

There was a big study done in the UK in 2019. At first they didn’t see any improvement(1) but when they broke the data down by age they showed a marked reduction in miscarriage in the PICSI group compared to the ICSI group. Which suggests PICSI may be hugely beneficial for older woken with partners over 35(2). But this is just one study and more are in the pipeline.

 

3. TESE, TESA & Micro-TESE


When sperm cannot be ejaculated or the DNA fragmentation remains extremely high, sperm can be collected directly from the testicle.

 

Why use testicular sperm?

Because sperm DNA fragmentation is often much lower inside the testicle compared to ejaculated sperm.

 

This makes testicular sperm especially helpful if:

  • There is very high DNA fragmentation

  • Fertilisation repeatedly fails

  • Embryo development stalls at day 3

  • Miscarriages keep happening

  • Ejaculated sperm are extremely poor quality

  • There is azoospermia (no sperm in ejaculate)

  • A man has had a vasectomy

 

Types of surgical retrieval

 

TESA (Testicular Sperm Aspiration)

A needle is used to extract sperm directly from the testicle.

 

TESE (Testicular Sperm Extraction)

A small tissue sample is removed surgically.

 

Micro-TESE

Uses a surgical microscope to find tiny pockets of sperm.

Best option for non-obstructive azoospermia.

 

Does it improve IVF outcomes?

 

In cases of severe DNA fragmentation, several clinics report:

  • Better embryo development

  • Higher blastocyst rates

  • Lower miscarriage rates

 

Not always necessary - but life-changing for couples where ejaculated sperm consistently underperform.

 

4. Donor Sperm

 

Sometimes, the only option is donor sperm.

 













This might be discussed when:

  • Micro-TESE finds no sperm

  • Severe genetic abnormalities are present

  • Sperm quality is extremely poor

  • Repeated IVF cycles fail due to sperm factor

  • A man carries a genetic condition the couple wish to avoid

  • Irreversible damage has occurred (chemotherapy, trauma, etc.)

 

Modern donor matching

 

Modern donor sperm is carefully screened, tested for over 100 genetic conditions, matched for physical characteristics, and often selected from donors with high sperm quality and fertility history.


Using donor sperm can bring up feelings of grief, identity questions, masculinity concerns, or worries over bonding with the baby, but many couples choose this path every year.

 

5. Choosing the Right Path: How Clinics Decide

 

Clinics typically look at:

  • Semen analysis

  • DNA fragmentation

  • Patient age

  • Embryo development patterns

  • Previous cycle outcomes

  • Fertilisation history

  • Presence of varicocele

  • Hormonal issues

  • Genetic test results

  • Personal preferences

 

Here’s a very simple roadmap:

 

If fertilisation fails → ICSI or PICSI

 

If sperm DNA fragmentation is high → PICSI and consider testicular sperm

 

If azoospermia → TESA/TESE/microTESE

 

If micro-TESE finds no sperm → donor sperm

 

If repeated miscarriages → sperm DNA testing + PICSI/TESE

 

Most couples don’t need all these tools - but knowing they exist is useful.

 

In summary

 

Male-factor infertility has multiple treatment paths.

 

Each one simply helps you reach your goal using the safest, most effective route for your situation.

 

  • ICSI: bypasses fertilisation issues

  • PICSI: selects more mature, lower-fragmentation sperm

  • TESE/TESA/micro-TESE: retrieves sperm directly when ejaculated sperm can’t be used

  • Donor sperm: a loving, valid, empowering path to parenthood


 
 
 

Comments


This website provides general educational information and is not medical advice. I am not a healthcare professional. Fertility treatment is highly individual, so always discuss your treatment, medications, supplements and test results with your fertility specialist or healthcare provider.

bottom of page