top of page
Search

Immune Testing in IVF

May 31
4 min read

Updated: Jul 28

Immune testing can be a confusing area in fertility treatment.

Some clinics treat it like essential detective work.

Others dismiss it as unnecessary, unscientific, or even exploitative.

 

Stuck in the middle is the woman who's had multiple transfers fail, early losses, unexplained infertility, lots of answers ruled out, and a gut feeling something deeper is going on.


This guide looks at what it is, who it helps, who it doesn't, and which tests are actually worth considering.

 

Why Immune Testing Even Exists


The idea behind reproductive immunology is simple:

 

Your immune system may play a role in whether an embryo implants or continues to grow.

 

This doesn’t mean your body is “attacking” your embryo - that’s too simplistic.

 

But immune dysregulation can influence:

  • Implantation

  • Early miscarriage

  • Chronic inflammation

  • Endometrial receptivity

  • NK cell activation

  • Embryo–endometrial communication

 

For some women, especially those with unexplained losses, immune testing offers answers they haven’t found anywhere else.

 

1. Natural Killer (NK) Cells

 

NK cells are part of the immune system.

They are supposed to be present in the uterus - they protect you, regulate implantation, and help remodel blood vessels.

 

They are not actually killers in pregnancy - the name is misleading.

 

Two types of NK tests:

 

a) Blood NK cells

 

These aren't rruly accurate for fertility because they test the overall NK cells in your body.

The doctor I saw didn't believe the blood test offered much insight but other doctors believe it does.

 

b) Uterine NK cells (endometrial biopsy)

 

These can sometimes reveal:

  • Excessively high or low NK cell density

  • Abnormal NK cell activation

  • Inflammatory issues

  • Chronic endometritis

  • Progesterone resistance

 

Although the evidence is mixed, uterine NK testing may be relevant for women with:

  • Multiple failed transfers

  • Recurrent early losses

  • Known autoimmune conditions

  • Unexplained implantation failure

 

But it is not a first-line test.

 

2. Intralipids

 

A fat-based IV infusion believed to reduce NK cell activation, calm inflammatory signalling, and create a more tolerant environment for implantation.

 

Evidence:

 

This is mixed.


Large studies show:

  • No clear improvement in live birth rates overall(1)(2)

  • Possible benefit in women with high uterine NK activation(3)(4)

 

Pros:

  • Low risk

  • Inexpensive compared to IVIG

  • Widely used internationally


Cons:

  • Not proven

  • Sometimes used unnecessarily

 

Intralipids fall into the category of “might help, unlikely to harm.”

 

3. Steroids (Prednisone / Prednisolone)

 

Steroids work by reducing inflammation and calming immune overactivity.

 

They are often prescribed for:

  • High NK activation

  • Autoimmune thyroid issues

  • Recurrent implantation failure

  • Suspected immune rejection

  • Adenomyosis or endometriosis

  • Chronic endometritis (after treatment)

 

Evidence:

 

Better than intralipids, but still mixed.

 

Steroids can help specific groups, especially those with(5):

  • Autoimmune markers

  • Elevated inflammatory markers

  • Endometrial immune dysregulation

 

They are not routinely recommended for all IVF patients.

 

4. IVIG (Intravenous Immunoglobulin)

 

This is the most controversial.

 

IVIG delivers concentrated antibodies from donated blood to modulate immune function.

 

Possible benefits:

 

  • Reduces overactive NK signalling

  • Improves immune tolerance

  • May help in recurrent miscarriage due to immune causes

 

Negatives:

 

  • Extremely expensive (£1,000–£5,000 per infusion)

  • Limited evidence

  • Potential side effects (rare but real)

  • Only appropriate in very specific cases

 

Most women do NOT need IVIG.

It is reserved for severe immune abnormalities under specialist care.

 

5. The DEFT Test (Dr Brosens)

 

This stands for “Decidualisation and Endometrial Function Test”. I took this test with Dr Brosen who is one of the leading recurrent implantation failure and early miscarriage doctors in the UK.

 

Dr. Jan Brosens is a leading figure in understanding why you might keep miscarrying or have repeated implantation failure.


The DEFT test is a pioneering diagnostic tool developed by Professor Jan Brosens to assess the preparedness of the womb lining for pregnancy. It is specifically designed to identify hidden defects in the endometrium that are often responsible for recurrent miscarriages and implantation failures. It is a biopsy-based test that evaluates the molecular signals in the womb lining to see if it responds correctly to pregnancy hormones (a process called the decidual reaction).


It involves a minor endometrial biopsy taken 5 to 11 days after ovulation.

The tissue is analyzed to determine if the womb lining is fully prepared to support an embryo and prevent early pregnancy loss.

 

Why decidualisation matters

 

If your lining doesn't respond properly to progesterone, implantation becomes difficult or impossible. The DEFT test can identify progesterone resistance, endometrial inflammation, chronic endometritis, embryo-endometrial asynchrony, poor receptivity, and suboptimal stromal cell response.


It may benefit women with recurrent miscarriage, repeated implantation failure, biochemical pregnancies, suspected progesterone resistance, endometriosis, or adenomyosis.


Unlike many immune tests, DEFT has growing scientific support and clinical rationale behind it, especially for recurrent lossIf your lining does not respond properly to progesterone, implantation becomes difficult or impossible(6).

 

6. Other Immune-Related Tests

 

Clinics may also offer:

  • Th1/Th2 cytokine ratio (blood)

  • TNF-alpha levels

  • Anti-phospholipid antibodies (APS screening) – good evidence(7)

  • ANA (antinuclear antibodies) – important for autoimmune diseases

  • HLA matching (KIR/HLA-C testing) – controversial, but used in very specific cases

  • Chronic endometritis test via ALICE – strong clinical relevance

  • Endometrial microbiome via EMMA – early evidence

 

Most of these are specialist tests, not routine tests.

 

7. So… Do Immune Issues Cause IVF Failure?

 

Sometimes. Not always. No-one truly knows yet.

 

It is believed to impact(8)(9):

  • Recurrent miscarriage

  • Repeated failed transfers

  • Unexplained infertility

  • Biochemical pregnancies

  • Endometrial inflammation

  • Implantation problems

 

The difficulty is knowing who falls into this group.

 

Immune treatment should be guided by your history, symptom, test results and your immunology specialist.

 

8. When Immune Testing Might Be Worth Considering

 

You may benefit from immune testing if you have:

  • 3+ failed transfers with good embryos

  • Recurrent miscarriages

  • Biochemical pregnancies

  • Suspected endometrial inflammation

  • Endometriosis or adenomyosis

  • Autoimmune conditions (thyroid, lupus, RA)

  • Chronic pelvic inflammation

  • Strong family history of autoimmune disease

  • Failed “perfect” cycles with no explanation

 

In these cases, immune investigation can uncover real, treatable issues.

 

You should never feel pushed into immune testing.

It should be carefully considered, not fear-driven.

 

In summary

 

  • Immune factors can play a role in IVF failure - but not for everyone

  • Uterine NK testing can help in specific cases

  • Intralipids & steroids can benefit certain women

  • IVIG is for specialist, severe cases only

  • The DEFT test is a promising tool for recurrent miscarriage or implantation failure

  • Most immune testing is optional, not essential

  • Your history matters more than a clinic’s sales pitch

 


 
 
 

Comments


This website provides general educational information and is not medical advice. I am not a healthcare professional. Fertility treatment is highly individual, so always discuss your treatment, medications, supplements and test results with your fertility specialist or healthcare provider.

bottom of page