top of page
Search

Fresh vs Frozen Embryo Transfer

May 26
3 min read

Updated: Jul 24

What’s the difference, which is better, and which option is right for you?

 

One of the big decisions in IVF - or sometimes a decision that gets made for you - is whether you’ll have a fresh embryo transfer or a frozen one.

 

On the surface, it sounds simple: fresh happens right after egg retrieval; frozen happens later.

 

But emotionally, physically, and scientifically, these two paths can feel very different.

 

Women often worry whether they’re choosing the “right” option.

The truth is: both work extremely well, and the choice usually comes down to what your body is doing, how your cycle went, and what your clinic feels is safest.

 

I was doing multiple cycles of IVF back to back so I was always going to do a frozen embryo transfer after all these had completed and I had tested my embryos, so this may be a factor too.

 

Let’s break it down so you understand exactly what each approach means.

 

What Is a Fresh Transfer?


A fresh transfer happens in the same cycle as your egg collection.

 

Timeline:

  • Stim injections

  • Egg collection

  • Embryo development

  • Transfer on day 3 or day 5

 

You stay on your medication (progesterone + sometimes estrogen) and go straight into the transfer.

 

Fresh transfer is usually possible when:

  • Your hormone levels look stable

  • Your lining is thick enough

  • You’re not at high risk of OHSS

  • Embryos are ready to transfer

  • Your body responds predictably

 

Why some women love fresh transfers:

  • You get your transfer sooner - emotionally rewarding

  • You don’t lose momentum

  • It feels “natural” - all happening in one cycle

  • No waiting for another month

 

For many, it feels like a smooth continuation of the process they’ve already invested so much time and energy into.

 

What Is a Frozen Transfer (FET)?

 

A frozen embryo transfer happens in a later cycle - weeks or months after egg collection.

 

Your embryos are frozen (vitrified) at blastocyst stage and thawed when you’re ready.

 

A FET can be done in:

  • A medicated cycle

  • A natural cycle

  • A modified natural cycle

 

Your clinic chooses the best approach for your body and hormones.

 

Why women often prefer FET:

  • Lower risk of cancelling due to hormones

  • Your ovaries are calm and recovered from stims

  • Your lining can be controlled more precisely

  • OHSS risk is eliminated or hugely reduced

  • Many studies show equal or sometimes higher success rates for frozen transfers

 

Key Differences

 

Fresh Transfer

  • Happens immediately

  • Fast and emotionally satisfying

  • Works very well for many women

  • BUT hormones from stims may affect the lining

  • And OHSS is a concern if you had lots of follicles

  • And high estrogen levels may reduce implantation in some cases

 

Frozen Transfer

  • Happens later

  • Gives your body time to recover

  • Allows a calmer, controlled environment

  • Can have excellent success rates

  • Safer for OHSS risk or high responders

  • Often preferred when doing PGT testing

 

Which One Has Better Success Rates?

 

This is the question everyone secretly wants to ask.

 

Short answer: Both are successful.

 

But context matters:

  • High responders, PCOS, or high oestrogen → frozen will be better

  • Normal responders → both options good

  • PGT-tested embryos → almost always frozen

  • Thin lining in fresh cycle → frozen may be better

  • OHSS risk → frozen is always safer

 

Some clinics push frozen-only cycles because it gives them more control.

Others still do fresh for women who are good candidates.

 

There are many studies that similar live birth rates between the 2 methods(1). But there are studies showing frozen embryo transfers may have higher live birth rates(2).

 

When Clinics Recommend a Frozen Transfer Instead of Fresh

 

Sometimes you don’t get a choice because your clinic wants to protect your health or improve your chances.

 

You may be advised to freeze all embryos if:

  • Your oestrogen levels went sky-high

  • You have PCOS and risk OHSS

  • You got a very high egg count

  • Your lining wasn’t ready

  • The cycle was chaotic

  • You want PGT testing

  • Your progesterone level rose at the wrong time

 

None of these situations mean the cycle was bad - just that your body needs a calmer environment for transfer.

 

Frozen is not a downgrade. Frozen is a smarter, safer, more controlled version in many cases.


So… Which One Should You Choose?

 

Trust your team, but also trust your instincts. Some women want to push on; others need the break.

 

Both paths can lead to the same outcome: a healthy embryo in the right environment.

 

What matters isn’t fresh vs frozen - it’s giving yourself the conditions, support, and timing that feel right for your body and your heart.

 


 
 
 

Comments


This website provides general educational information and is not medical advice. I am not a healthcare professional. Fertility treatment is highly individual, so always discuss your treatment, medications, supplements and test results with your fertility specialist or healthcare provider.

bottom of page