top of page
Search

Endometrial Scratch

May 31
3 min read

Updated: Jul 28

The endometrial scratch is one of those IVF add-ons that exploded in popularity almost overnight.

 

Doctors started recommending it. Clinics began offering it. Forums raved about it.

 

Women whispered about it like a secret trick that might finally make implantation work.

 

But over time, the science has caught up - and the truth is far more measured than the hype.

 

Let’s see what the scratch actually is, why it was once so widely used, and whether it’s worth considering today.

 

What Is the Endometrial Scratch?

 

The endometrial scratch is a small, quick procedure where the doctor deliberately scrapes or “disturbs” the lining of the uterus (endometrium).


It’s typically done using:

  • A thin catheter

  • A pipelle biopsy tube

  • Or a curette-like device

 

It takes just a few minutes and feels similar to a strong smear test or a crampy biopsy.

 

Why Was It Believed to Help?

 

The original idea was that “injuring” the lining would trigger a healing response.

 

The theory went like this:

  • Create a tiny injury →

  • The body sends growth factors and immune cells to repair it →

  • The endometrium becomes more receptive for implantation →

  • Embryo sticks more easily

 

This concept was appealing because it felt like a simple, low-cost way to improve success rates.

 

Early small studies even suggested it might help — especially in women who had repeated failed transfers(1)(2).

 

So clinics jumped on it.

 

What the New Evidence Shows

 

High-quality, large-scale trials have now shown:

 

The endometrial scratch does NOT improve pregnancy rates for most women

 

The biggest and best trial (the 2019 PREDICT study)(4) showed:

  • No increase in live birth rates

  • No improvement in implantation

  • No benefit for first-time IVF

  • No benefit for repeated failures

  • No benefit in fresh cycles

  • No benefit in frozen cycles

 

As a result, fertility societies like:

  • HFEA (UK)

  • ESHRE (Europe)

  • ASRM (USA)

 

now recommend against routine use of the scratch.

 

It is now classified in the UK as a “red” add-on - meaning evidence shows no improvement in live birth rates.

 

Does Anyone Still Benefit?

 

Possibly, but only in very specific situations.

 

Some clinicians still consider the scratch for:

  • Women with several failed transfers and

  • Suspected endometrial issues

  • Chronic endometritis (inflammation)

  • Poor endometrial development despite medication

 

But this is individualised, not routine.

 

For the average IVF patient, evidence does not support its use.

 

Does It Cause Harm?

 

Generally the scratch is low risk, quick, and safe, but it can cause pain, cramping, bleeding, rare infection, unnecessary expense, and unnecessary hope placed in an ineffective procedure. So while it's not seriously harmful, it does carry the emotional risk of doing one more thing that doesn't actually increase your chances.


Most doctors say it shouldn't be done in the same cycle as a transfer, but rather the cycle before, so the lining can heal.

 

Cost: Is It Worth Paying For?

 


Typical cost: £150–£400.

 

Given the current evidence, most women are better off saving that money for something with clearer benefit - or simply keeping it in their pocket.

 

The scratch is no longer considered worth paying for unless a doctor has a very specific medical reason related to your case.

 

In summary

 

  • The endometrial scratch sounds promising but does not improve IVF success rates for most women.

  • Major fertility bodies now discourage routine use.

  • It may have limited benefit in unusual, very specific cases.

  • Clinics offering it as a standard add-on are not following the current evidence.

  • You are not harming your chances by skipping it.

  • You do not need to do “everything” in order to deserve success.

 

Your embryo will not implant (or fail to implant) because of a scratch.

It will implant because it is healthy, the timing is right, and biology aligns.

 

 



 
 
 

Comments


This website provides general educational information and is not medical advice. I am not a healthcare professional. Fertility treatment is highly individual, so always discuss your treatment, medications, supplements and test results with your fertility specialist or healthcare provider.

bottom of page