top of page
Search

Choosing the Right Donor

Jun 14
4 min read

Updated: Jul 28

Choosing a donor - whether egg, sperm, or both - can be a difficult decision.

 

It can feel exciting, overwhelming, deeply meaningful, and sometimes confusing. It took me AGES!

 

BUT - there is no “perfect” donor. There is only the donor who feels right for you.

 

1. Start With the Most Important Question

 

Before reading any profiles, ask yourself what qualities matter most to you in a future child, and why.


People often choose based on resemblance, personality, medical history, values, education, hobbies, or simply a feeling.


Others choose based on practicality: availability, cost, clinic recommendations, or identity-release rules.


Your right donor is the one who aligns with your values and feels emotionally comfortable.

 

2. What People Commonly Look For

 

Here are the most common factors recipients consider.

 

A. Physical Traits

Many people prefer a donor who could “blend in” with the family.

 

Common considerations:

  • Hair colour

  • Eye colour

  • Height

  • Build

  • Skin tone

  • Ethnicity

  • Facial features

 

This is especially important for single parents, same-sex couples or families who want physical resemblance with one partner

 

But it’s also worth remembering that children inherit traits in unpredictable ways, even with genetic parents.

 

Focus on general resemblance, not perfection.

 

B. Ethnicity & Cultural Background

Many recipients choose donors who share:

  • Their own ethnic background

  • Their partner’s background

  • A mix of both

  • Their cultural or religious identity

 

This can feel important for family resemblance, cultural connection, easier conversations with extended family and for navigating future identity questions.

 

C. Medical History & Genetic Screening

This is one of the most important practical factors.

 

Look for:

  • Extensive genetic screening

  • Family medical history (parents, siblings, grandparents)

  • Absence of serious hereditary conditions

  • Carrier status for any recessive conditions

 

If both you and the donor carry the same recessive condition, the clinic will usually recommend choosing another donor.

 

D. Personality, Interests & Education

These are optional but meaningful for many parents.

 

Profiles may include:

  • Hobbies

  • Temperament

  • Academic background

  • Career path

  • Values

  • Creativity or artistic traits

  • Athletic abilities

 

Some people choose a donor who reminds them of themselves, their partner, a family member or someone they admire

 

Others prioritise traits they hope to pass to their future child.

 

There is no wrong approach.

 

E. Donor Type: Anonymous vs Identity-Release

This is one of the biggest decisions - and the answer depends entirely on your values.

 

Identity-Release Donors (UK, US, Denmark, Australia)

  • Child can access identifying info at 18

  • No contact before then

  • Aligns with openness and transparency

  • Future child has the choice to know

 

Anonymous Donors (Spain, Slovakia, Czech Republic)

  • No identifying info

  • Sometimes a broader choice

  • Often more affordable

  • Simplifies boundaries

 

Many families choose anonymous donors for privacy.

Others choose identity-release to give their child future options.

 

To me it was important to be able to give my future child the option to discover their biological background.

 

F. Donor Reason for Donating

This can be surprisingly meaningful.

 

Profiles often include a personal note about why the donor chose to donate, what they hope for the future family and what values matter to them

 

Some recipients find a donor’s message comforting, emotional, or even the deciding factor.

 

G. Photos & Audio Profiles (if available)


Depending on country, childhood photos, adult photos, audio interviews, essays, or videos, helping many get a feel for the donor beyond the medical data. But remember, the right donor isn't necessarily the best-looking profile, it's the one who feels aligned with you.

 






3. Things That Feel Important but Aren’t Actually Predictive

 

Many people get stuck obsessing over tiny details.

 

Here are things that don’t significantly predict your child’s future:

  • Whether the donor likes football or painting

  • Exact A-level or university grades

  • Height down to the centimetre

  • Donor’s favourite books or films

  • Whether the donor is an introvert or extrovert

  • Childhood photo cuteness (kids change dramatically!)

 

These can play a role emotionally, but they don’t determine your child’s personality or success.

 

Focus on the traits that matter most to you, not perfection.

 

4. Choosing a Donor as a Single Woman or Same-Sex Couple

 

This choice can feel even more meaningful.

 

Many consider:

  • Resemblance to the non-carrying parent

  • Physical matching

  • Emotional alignment

  • Donor values

  • Identity-release options for the future child

  • Cultural background

  • Medical history

  • Future potential for siblings


For same-sex couples, some choose alternating donors for siblings.

Others use one donor for consistency.

 

5. Choosing a Donor as a Heterosexual Couple with Male-Factor Infertility

 

This can be emotionally complex.

 

Partners may worry about resemblance, bonding, masculinity identity or grief

 

The right donor often resembles the male partner, shares traits he values, eases the transition emotionally and feels “right” or comforting during the decision

 

Counselling is incredibly helpful here, and clinics encourage it for a reason: to help everyone feel emotionally ready and supported.

 

6. How to Narrow Down the List Without Losing Your Sanity

 

Here’s a simple but powerful method:

 

Step 1: Choose the non-negotiables

 

For example:

  • Ethnicity

  • Medical screening

  • Identity-release vs anonymous

 

Step 2: Pick 3–5 “nice to have” traits

 

Such as:

  • Height

  • Personality type

  • Education

  • Hobbies

 

Step 3: Read donor letters or audio clips (if available)

 

These often create an emotional connection.

 

Step 4: Trust your intuition

 

This is genuinely the deciding factor for many families.

 

Most people describe a moment where they simply know.

 

Step 5: Stop looking once you’ve chosen

 

Endless searching increases anxiety.

 

The right donor is someone you feel peaceful - or at least comfortable - choosing.

 

7. Questions to Ask Yourself


  • What qualities do I hope my future child inherits?

  • How important is physical resemblance?

  • Do I want the donor to be identity-release?

  • How much information do I want available for the child later?

  • Does this donor feel aligned emotionally?

  • Is this decision easing my anxiety or increasing it?

  • Can I imagine telling my future child about this donor with ease and pride?

 

These questions guide you toward clarity.

 

8. Things That Help When You Feel Overwhelmed

 

  • Limit the number of profiles you view per day

  • Ask yourself which profile made you feel calm, not anxious

  • Remember there is no “perfect” donor - only the right one for your family

  • Counselling is incredibly helpful

  • Talk to others who’ve used donors (online groups, support networks)

  • Remember: genetics do not define parenthood

 

In summary

 

Choosing a donor is deeply personal. The right donor isn't the smartest, tallest, or most photogenic, it's the one who makes you feel peaceful, hopeful, and connected to your decision.


Your child's identity will be shaped by your love, your home, your values, your parenting, your relationship, and the environment you create. DNA is just one small part of their story, and not the most important one.

 
 
 

Comments


This website provides general educational information and is not medical advice. I am not a healthcare professional. Fertility treatment is highly individual, so always discuss your treatment, medications, supplements and test results with your fertility specialist or healthcare provider.

bottom of page